However, having a tool synonymous with a practice can be bad thing because people can get carried away with the various bells and whistles different CI servers provide. Don’t get me wrong, I’m a big fan of CruiseControl and other CI servers, but let’s not get lulled into thinking that the tool is what provides the practice. Vendors may want us to think this, but we’re smarter than this, right?
So while I love MSI, I love it as a tool that implements sound practices... practices that can also be accomplished using other NON-MSI tools.
So with that in mind, a friend recently forwarded me this email stating that Windows Installer is being dropped from WS08 Logo requirements.
From: Meg Muran (Corestaff) [mailto: email@example.com]
Sent: Thursday, September 06, 2007 4:34 PM
Subject: PLEASE READ: Change in WS08 Certification Requirements
MSI installation is now RECOMMENDED/OPTIONAL and no longer REQUIRED. This should make your development team very happy if, like many ISVs, the MSI installation requirement has been blocking your path to certification.
The following language (or something very similar) will replace the existing section of the certification requirements documents and tools available at www.innovateonwindowsserver.com. As always, firstname.lastname@example.org is the technical support alias you should use for all certification-related issues.
Installation requirements in detail
2.1 Installer related requirements
Use Windows Components for Installation.
Using the built in installation engines creates consistent, reversible, transacted installations. This ensures the quality of the user's application experience upon installation and throughout the software lifecycle.
Ø It is optional and recommended that application use use the Windows Installer (MSI) or ClickOnce for installation. When using Windows Installer, Installation packages must not receive any errors from the Internal Consistency Evaluators (ICEs) listed here:
1-24, 27-31, 33-36, 38-57, 59, 61-63, 65, 67-72, 74-84, 86-87, 89-94, 96-99
Warnings represent design guidance to the package author which should be studied for applicability. Any warnings that do not apply or will not be fixed must be documented.
If your applications setup is a non-MSI based setup it must be clearly documented as part of the Logo submission documentation. If any generic installation requirement outlined in this document applies to your installer, then they must be satisfied as well.
A variety of third-party tools are available that can be used to create Windows Installation packages. The ICEs can be run from the Orca application, which ships with the Windows SDK.
For information on ICE, see:
Ø Support command line installation
Applications must support command line install uninstall. This applies to applications regardless of the use of Windows Installer.
Applications using Windows Installer must successfully install in quiet mode via a command line with /qn switch.
All command line options for install uninstall must be clearly documented.
Meg Muran (Corestaff)
Windows Server Marketing - Logo Team